It's Independence Day
Jul. 4th, 2008 10:42 am![[personal profile]](https://www.dreamwidth.org/img/silk/identity/user.png){kind=small}
amari_zHappy Independence Day to all my US f-listers. This day seems an appropriate one to muse on something that’s been on my mind a lot in recent years, but which was particularly triggered by a truck I’ve seen parked outside my building for the last week. As I might have mentioned once or twice before, there’s a big construction pit right outside my door. One of the trucks stationed to collect debris has stenciled across the front: “AMERICA LOVE IT OR LEAVE IT!!!” The sight of this demand (threat?) sours my mood each day as I approach home. This sort of rhetoric is a sore point, especially now when it has become commonplace in our political discourse to call any criticism of the government unpatriotic and a betrayal of the country.
On this, the day we mark the 232nd anniversary of the signing of the Declaration of Independence, I find myself wanting to remember that this country was founded by the revolt of people who, whatever their other faults and virtues, were deeply distrustful of the power of government. They in fact were so wary that the first national government they created was so weak as to be disastrously ineffective. It was only after this failed attempt that they drafted the Constitution that is the basis of our government today, and its Framers had to work hard to convince the suspicious nation to accept the stronger national government it created. The Constitution, which provided for a far weaker executive branch then we’ve come to have today, is built on a concept of checks and balances, a theory that embraces inefficiencies in government and pits separate, equal branches of government against each other. The Framers viewed this systematic inefficiency as preferable to the danger inherent in a more streamlined, and hence more efficient and effective, government. They feared the danger of power collecting into one person or groups’ hands. None of the Founding Fathers would recognize the concept that debate and dissent were unpatriotic--in fact they would argue the opposite. Debate and dissent (if one disagreed) were the responsibility--the duty--of the citizenry, which would be informed by a free and vigilant press.
This is not a controversial reading of early American history. To truly love this country, to protect its founding ideals, is to be willing to take the time and have the courage to scrutinize the actions of those who hold office and to voice support or dissent. A state where the government’s policies must be supported without debate and dissent is not in keeping with the Republic declared on this day over two centuries ago; it is instead the foundation of a fascist state.
We’ve all heard the excuses for the abuses of the current administration too often: that we’re fighting a war like no other; that drastic measures are necessary for survival; that unless we hand over some liberties, the enemy will win.* But this is bullshit. It’s an excuse that echoes the rhetoric of the Nazi party when it took control of Germany. And even if it’s correct--if preserving our ideals, our free state, costs us something in safety--is the alternative really preferable? What, then, are we are seeking to protect? Ben Franklin once wrote, “They who can give up essential liberty to obtain a little temporary safety, deserve neither liberty nor safety.” I’ve thought of this often in the last seven or so years.
So on this day of barbeques, fireworks and celebration, let’s not forget what it means to be truly patriotic. I say this not so much for you, my fabulous f-list, for I realize I’m largely preaching to the choir, but for myself, as a reminder that, while I find so many activities of the United States’ government morally, ethically, and legally repugnant and am made ashamed and afraid by them, I do love this country for the ideals it is supposed to stand for. The Framers called it the quest for a more perfect union. It is a quest that recognizes that democracy, liberty and justice are fragile aspirations that a vigilant citizenry must constantly define and strive for, and not something that any administration, party or politician can complacently claim to possess.
“Guard against the impostures of pretended patriotism.”
~George Washington
“America will never be destroyed from the outside. If we falter and lose our freedoms, it will be because we destroyed ourselves.”
~Abraham Lincoln
Happy Birthday, America.
*But lest it be thought that there’s no need to fret on these matters, since it looks possible that the Democrats will gain the White House in the next election and that the last years will come to be an aberration, a nightmare, from which we will awaken, remember that it was a Democratic Congress that recently passed legislation immunizing telecom companies from their illegal spying, that the passed the wiretap law legitimizing the administrations’ ability to tap our conversations without judicial supervision, that has permitted the Guantanamo incarcerations and “trials” to go on, and that has failed to act to prevent what any rational person can only call state-sanctioned torture.
On this, the day we mark the 232nd anniversary of the signing of the Declaration of Independence, I find myself wanting to remember that this country was founded by the revolt of people who, whatever their other faults and virtues, were deeply distrustful of the power of government. They in fact were so wary that the first national government they created was so weak as to be disastrously ineffective. It was only after this failed attempt that they drafted the Constitution that is the basis of our government today, and its Framers had to work hard to convince the suspicious nation to accept the stronger national government it created. The Constitution, which provided for a far weaker executive branch then we’ve come to have today, is built on a concept of checks and balances, a theory that embraces inefficiencies in government and pits separate, equal branches of government against each other. The Framers viewed this systematic inefficiency as preferable to the danger inherent in a more streamlined, and hence more efficient and effective, government. They feared the danger of power collecting into one person or groups’ hands. None of the Founding Fathers would recognize the concept that debate and dissent were unpatriotic--in fact they would argue the opposite. Debate and dissent (if one disagreed) were the responsibility--the duty--of the citizenry, which would be informed by a free and vigilant press.
This is not a controversial reading of early American history. To truly love this country, to protect its founding ideals, is to be willing to take the time and have the courage to scrutinize the actions of those who hold office and to voice support or dissent. A state where the government’s policies must be supported without debate and dissent is not in keeping with the Republic declared on this day over two centuries ago; it is instead the foundation of a fascist state.
We’ve all heard the excuses for the abuses of the current administration too often: that we’re fighting a war like no other; that drastic measures are necessary for survival; that unless we hand over some liberties, the enemy will win.* But this is bullshit. It’s an excuse that echoes the rhetoric of the Nazi party when it took control of Germany. And even if it’s correct--if preserving our ideals, our free state, costs us something in safety--is the alternative really preferable? What, then, are we are seeking to protect? Ben Franklin once wrote, “They who can give up essential liberty to obtain a little temporary safety, deserve neither liberty nor safety.” I’ve thought of this often in the last seven or so years.
So on this day of barbeques, fireworks and celebration, let’s not forget what it means to be truly patriotic. I say this not so much for you, my fabulous f-list, for I realize I’m largely preaching to the choir, but for myself, as a reminder that, while I find so many activities of the United States’ government morally, ethically, and legally repugnant and am made ashamed and afraid by them, I do love this country for the ideals it is supposed to stand for. The Framers called it the quest for a more perfect union. It is a quest that recognizes that democracy, liberty and justice are fragile aspirations that a vigilant citizenry must constantly define and strive for, and not something that any administration, party or politician can complacently claim to possess.
“Guard against the impostures of pretended patriotism.”
~George Washington
“America will never be destroyed from the outside. If we falter and lose our freedoms, it will be because we destroyed ourselves.”
~Abraham Lincoln
Happy Birthday, America.
*But lest it be thought that there’s no need to fret on these matters, since it looks possible that the Democrats will gain the White House in the next election and that the last years will come to be an aberration, a nightmare, from which we will awaken, remember that it was a Democratic Congress that recently passed legislation immunizing telecom companies from their illegal spying, that the passed the wiretap law legitimizing the administrations’ ability to tap our conversations without judicial supervision, that has permitted the Guantanamo incarcerations and “trials” to go on, and that has failed to act to prevent what any rational person can only call state-sanctioned torture.
![[identity profile]](https://www.dreamwidth.org/img/silk/identity/openid.png){kind=small}
no subject
Date: 2008-07-04 02:58 pm (UTC)Hear, hear!
Hope you have a lovely holiday weekend! I'll be around Sunday, defrosting my ancient fridge. Are you up for some Persian food?
no subject
Date: 2008-07-04 11:51 pm (UTC)We seem to have the same issues/problems North of the Border. Only we are told that we complain too much and that is just so lame of us to whine continuously. I beg to differ. I feel it's my right as a citizen to voice my complaints about what our illustrious government is currently screwing up. After all, I voted the morons into office and I should be able to let them know when I am unhappy about another of their harebrained ideas.
Sadly our politicians are too busy spin doctoring their faux pas to actually pay attention. I could mention the former Hell's Angel biker babe who dated our minister of defense. Said minister "forgot" sensitive government documents on her coffee table. *headdesk* Not to worry! She said she never looked and didn't share the sensitive data with anyone. Heck, I believe her O_o NOT!!!
Take care,
Shelley
no subject
Date: 2008-07-06 10:49 pm (UTC)no subject
Date: 2008-07-06 11:22 pm (UTC)I do believe in people's right to govern themselves, but the problem is that rarely are governments actually controlled by the people. (I fear that we are moving increasingly in that direction ourselves.) And rarely are countries homogenous--so even in "democratic" countries, there is the possibility of great injustices. On one hand, there should be some kind of moral imperative to act to prevent atrocities (Bosnia, Sudan). On the other, such efforts are paternalistic, too often an excuse for self-interested agendas rather than any actual humanitarian concerns (Iraq), and, history shows, they will rarely be successful.
I've been down visiting the family, so I just listened to your vm. (I'm on a bus headed back to NY, and the traffic is HORRIBLE--so it's going to take a long while.) I looked up the book you found, and I think I do remember it from back in the days of yore where no new Arthurian book would have evaded me, although I'd forgotten all about it until your vm stirred some vague recollection. I don't remember reading it, though. Even if it's decent, I'm going to have to avoid it--don't want to contaminate the well. ;)
Hope you had a good weekend! I'm hoping not to be too busy this week, so feel free to call if you have time. I'd try you now, except I hate talking while on the bus--everyone around you can hear, and it incites my rage when others do it.
no subject
Date: 2008-07-06 11:49 pm (UTC)I apologize if I offended you.
no subject
Date: 2008-07-05 04:29 am (UTC)no subject
Date: 2008-07-06 10:51 pm (UTC)no subject
Date: 2008-09-08 05:49 am (UTC)Id love to see you there.
thanks so much for your time.
-Faith